SCAM AWARENESS EDUCATION SERIES

The digital landscape has become a fertile ground for sophisticated online fraudsters. Catching these criminals requires a combination of vigilance, understanding their tactics, and knowing the proper steps to take when you encounter a scam. It’s less about a high-speed pursuit and more about careful documentation and reporting.

1. Recognizing the Fraudster’s Tactics

The first step in “catching” a fraudster is to identify their presence before they can cause harm. Online scammers rely on a few universal tactics, regardless of the specific scam (e.g., phishing, fake shopping sites, romance scams).

• Impersonation: They often pretend to be a trusted entity—a bank, a government agency (like the IRS or Social Security Administration), a tech support company, or even a friend or family member whose account has been compromised. They may use similar logos and slightly altered domain names.

• Urgency and Pressure: Fraudsters create a false sense of urgency, threatening immediate consequences (like arrest, account closure, or a dire family emergency) if you don’t act right now. This pressure aims to bypass rational thought and prevent you from verifying their claims.

• Suspicious Payment Methods: A major red flag is when they demand payment in specific, hard-to-trace ways, such as:

  • Gift cards (e.g., Apple, Google Play)

  • Wire transfers (e.g., Western Union)

  • Cryptocurrency

  • Payment apps without buyer protection

• Too Good to Be True Offers: Scams frequently promise massive rewards—winning a lottery, getting a job with high pay and no experience required, or products sold at an unbelievably low price. If an offer seems unrealistic, it almost certainly is.

2. Documenting the Evidence (The “Catching” Phase)

If you are targeted by a scammer, your primary role in catching them is to become a thorough evidence collector. Law enforcement and regulatory agencies need details to trace and prosecute these criminals.

• Gather Contact Information: Document everything you can about how they contacted you:

  • Email Address: Save the entire email, including the header information (which shows the route the email took).

  • Phone Number: Note the phone number they called from or asked you to call back.

  • Profile/Account Names: Get screenshots of any social media profiles, usernames, or account handles they used.

• Preserve Conversations: Take screenshots of all messages—texts, emails, chat logs, or social media direct messages. Crucially, document the entire interaction, particularly any requests for money or personal information.

• Record Transaction Details: If you made a payment, record the date, time, amount, and the method of payment (e.g., which gift card brand, the wallet address for crypto). If they provided bank account details for a deposit, save those as well.

• Identify Compromised Accounts: If the scam involved a malicious attachment or a fraudulent website login, immediately change the passwords for those accounts and enable multi-factor authentication (MFA). Scan your device for malware.

3. Reporting to the Authorities and Institutions

The final, and most critical, step in catching online fraudsters is reporting the crime. These reports allow agencies to track patterns, consolidate cases, and initiate investigations.

1. Notify Your Financial Institutions

If you lost money or shared financial information, your bank, credit card company, or payment app must be the first call. They can take steps to freeze accounts, reverse fraudulent charges (if possible), and monitor for identity theft.

2. File a Government Report

Official reports provide law enforcement with the data needed to trace and prosecute offenders.

• Federal/National Authorities: Report the crime to the appropriate national center for internet-related crime. You must provide as many details and as much evidence as possible.

• Local Law Enforcement: File a report with your local police department, especially if you lost a significant amount of money or if the crime occurred offline as well (e.g., the scammer showed up in person).

3. Report to the Platform

Report the fraudulent activity to the platform where it occurred. This could be:

• The social media site (Facebook, Instagram, etc.)

• The email provider (Gmail, Outlook, etc.)

• The online marketplace or shopping platform (eBay, Amazon, etc.)

Reporting to the platform helps them shut down the fake accounts, preventing others from being victimized by the same scammer.

By being cautious, documenting every suspicious interaction, and promptly reporting to the correct authorities, you become a crucial part of the system that works to expose and ultimately stop online fraudsters.

strongest defense.   

Contact us if you’d like more information on how cyber intelligence can help you locate scammers.

Please share this guide with friends and colleagues.